coat-of-arms-crest-flag-swiss-key-emblemLocked Room Mysteries

Find an impossible murder!

A Proud Amazon Associate!

Hake Talbot

Hake Talbot is a pen name of American lawyer, theatrical director, amateur magician and novelist, Henning Nelms (1900-1986). Talbot is now chiefly remembered for his locked room mystery novel ‘Rim of the Pit’ (1944).

During a 1981 poll of experts, arranged by Edward D. Hoch for the preface of his anthology ‘All But Impossible!’, Talbot’s ‘Rim of the Pit’ stood second, next only to John Dickson Carr’s ‘The Hollow Man’ (1935), as the best locked room mystery of all time. Another of Talbot’s novels, ‘The Hangman’s Handyman’, which Talbot wrote in 1942, also received honourable mention, and he wrote two important short stories, ‘The High House’ and ‘The Other Side’.

After 1945, it became more difficult to publish mystery fiction, and Nelms could not get his third novel published. He then stopped writing fiction and to this day no copy of this third novel, reportedly titled ‘The Affair of the Half-Witness’, has ever been found. Nelms is also widely remembered as an amateur stage magician, who wrote several important works on this art. His ‘Magic and Showmanship: A Handbook for Conjurers’, is widely considered to be one of the most important texts on the performance of stage magic. He was an active member of the Society of American Magicians and taught drama at Middlebury College, Vermont. He also wrote the play ‘Only an Orphan Girl’ (1944). 

Mike Grost: Later Impossible Crime Fiction

“Hake Talbot only published two novels, a play and some short fiction, so his output was very small. Talbot’s first novel, Hangman’s Handyman (1942), is disappointing. But his second novel, Rim of the Pit (1944), is a masterpiece. Talbot is the only Carr imitator whose work could actually be preferred to that of Carr himself. Both of these novels are now back in print, from the publisher Ramble House.”

HangmanHangman’s Handyman (1942)
Series: Rogan Kincaid



Best Review

Available in paperback and ebook editions.

Book  eBook  eBook

Note: A fairly good first novel

Reviewers generally agree that this first effort was not in the same league as his classic ‘Rim of The Pit’, though some disagree (See link below). Rogan Kincaid arrives at the mysterious island known as The Kraken, expecting to attend a lavish party thrown by Jackson B. Frant for a dozen guests. Instead he finds only  Nancy Garwood, who has been drugged and left in her bedroom. The rest of the mansion is deserted and all Nancy remembers is that somebody died at dinner! 

During the course of this novel a man is apparently killed by a spoken curse, after which his body begins to immediately decompose. There is also an attempted murder inside a locked room.

More on: ‘Hangman’s Handyman’

Rim of PitRim of The Pit (1944)
Rogan Kincaid Series



Locked Room Review

Available in paperback and ebook editions.

Book  eBook  eBook

Note: #2 on the all time list of locked room mysteries!

A true locked room classic. Second only to ‘The Hollow Man’ on Hoch’s 1981 list of best locked room mysteries of all time!

A snowbound group of people in the north woods must deal with a supernatural killer unleashed by a seance. Locked rooms and impossible murders seem to be explainable only by believing that the dead can come back to take revenge on the living. Footprints that begin and end in the middle of unbroken snowfields, the appearance of a Wendigo that can swoop down on its victims, someone killed by someone possessed by a dead man — these are some of the puzzles adventurer Rogan Kinkaid faces in the classic Locked Room novel.

More on: ‘Rim of The Pit’

Hake Talbot Short Stories

Art ImpossibleThe Other Side
Series: Rogan Kincaid Series
Collection: Murder Impossible, Ed: J. Adrian & Robert Adey. 


Best Review

Available only in used hardcover.


Note: A religious cult haunts Hollywood

“The Other Side” features Talbot’s central character, Rogan Kincaid, this time assisted by Svetozar Vok. The victim is shot to death while alone inside a locked room under constant observation. The novel is set in Hollywood and involves the machinations of a dangerous religious cult. Talbot again deals with the power of curses, much like those found in ‘Hangman’s Handyman’.

mystery_book_1948The High House (1948)
Series: Rogan Kincaid Series
Collection: Mystery Book Magazine, Spring, 1948 (Vol.6 #3)


Best Review

Available only in the original magazine. Some issues on eBay, can’t currently locate this title: Mystery Book Magazine [v6 #3, Spring 1948] (25¢, pulp) Other issues $15 – $45, this one likely much more!

Note: Death by falling from a rooftop?

Mike Grost: Later Impossible Crime Fiction

“The High House” (1948) has an impossible crime based in the architecture of its remote country mansion, like some of the miracles in Rim of the Pit. This sort of concern for architecture was a Golden Age specialty. Rogan Kincaid has manipulated a few events behind the scenes, actions we learn about in the finale, as in Rim of the Pit. And it deals with a curse that threatens to annihilate the hero of the story, as in Hangman’s Handyman. The story has some of Talbot’s trademark atmosphere, with a group of characters stuck in a remote place where eeriness reigns. There is an odd feel of time having stopped, while we watch strange events unfold as in a dream. There is also a complex series of interrelationships between the characters in the story: Talbot has worked out the special nature of the relationship between each pair of the story’s characters. This too adds to the feeling of plot density and weight.”

Hake Talbot Bibliography

Locked Room 101: The Masters

The Locked Room Mystery home


Hake Talbot — No Comments

Leave a Reply